I wrote about this comic strip and these two guys a few days ago. Sunday, maybe? I don’t think I made this statement then: “The Argyle Sweater is funny.” I should have, because it is. At the time I was caught up in the idea that The Argyle Sweater, which for some reason I want to call The Argyle Sock, closely resembled The Far Side by Gary Larson.
Well, what is wrong with that? Nothing. Some critics have made the point that Hilburn occasionally has a joke that is similar to one Larson made; okay, are they implying that once an original thought occurs, no one can have an idea like that, even if they express it well, even if they make you . . . smile?
Gee, scientists, you can’t do gravity – Newton did it. Or how about this: A guy or gal has a brain tumor and a really good surgeon is able to delve deep and remove it and have the patient recover and be pretty normal. Do you send him away because he is doing something like an earlier surgeon did? Of course not. He can get the job done.
The Argyle Sweater gets the job done; Hilburn courts humor and lets it manifest itself in that off the wall way Larson did. Great, because for one thing, Larson isn’t doing it anymore in a daily strip. Personally, I like to have my brain regularly tickled by takes on situations that are far beyond knock-knock jokes; we should all utter a collective “Thank You, Mr. Hilburn, for showing us the thoughts you have when you let your mind hear a different drummer . . . well, in cases like this, maybe a different tuba.”
Oom, Oom Pah . . . Pah, Pah, Oom . . .
Oh, that’s sort of a complicated collective thought – so let’s just make the “Thank You” collective and you can customize the elaboration.